- The Top Amateur Golfballs
- And The Winner Is…
- TaylorMade Project (s) Golf Balls
Just because a PGA tour pro plays Titleist ProV1 or Callaway Performance balls does not mean amateurs should use the same golf balls.
A tour-level professional has a different skill level and requirement than a weekend warrior. We wanted to help you find the best golf ball for amateurs, and give you some options when it comes to choosing the best ball for your game.
What Is The Best Golf Ball for Amateur Golfers?
This is a very tough question to answer because there are a lot of variables that would go into determining “what is the best golf balls for amateurs.” I think a lot would depend on things like:
- Swing speed
- Your preferred trajectory
- Your ball flight
- How much spin control do you like approaching the greens?
- Does greenside control matter to you?
- Do you require less driver spin for a straighter ball flight?
- Are you looking for extra distance?
- What is your distance off the tee?
- What type of feel do you like in your golf ball – soft or firm?
- What kind of core do you like?
An amateur golfer at your golf club with a 4 handicap is going to have a much different answer compared to the 18 handicap that has trouble keeping the ball in play off of the tee. Our definition of an amateur golfer is anyone we can play with regularly, and we are not referring to professional golfers. Although this review is more focused on the 10+ handicap, we do include some premium balls from some of the best golf ball manufacturers.
Your Skill Level Is Going To Determine What Ball is Best For Your
If you are very new to the game and go through a dozen golf balls each round, performance, compression, core, and trajectory mean nothing to you. You should look for an affordable ball for under $20 a dozen that will feel good when you hit them well.
Price point should be more important to you than performance. If you are very new and a high handicapper, your reasons for choosing your ball are based more on money and experience rather than specifications and technology.
What is the Best Golf Ball for the Average Player?
Once again, we have to define what we believe to be the average player. The average handicap of an amateur golfer is 18, so we are still referring to amateur golfers that make a bogey on every hole. For this skill level, we are still not convinced that a performance ball is worth the money.
Technology is going to help our average golfer, but we are still looking for balls that are straighter on iron shots, and provide more accuracy compared to feel. Spin is important to the average golfer of an 18 handicap, but not for performance around the green. Higher handicappers need speed to keep their driver and irons in line and straight. This is where we want to take advantage of technology.
The average player or amateur is generally looking for a ball that has a good feel and comes off the driver with some power and speed, is a compression or urethane core, and won’t cost us too much money. When you search for the best golf balls for amateurs, realize you should be able to afford to hit it in the water or out of bounds, as that is the experience and skill level of this type of golfer.
What is the Best Golf Ball for Mid Handicappers?
Mid handicappers are going to have a bit more skill than amateurs and are going to require will likely want a golf ball to match their swing speed and level of experience. When we get into the mid handicapper range of 10 to 18, we are looking for a ball with more feel, more spin, a premium cover and core, and one that can be moved from side to side with the driver and on iron shots.
With the Mid Handicapper, he or she is going to start to think more about how their golf balls react on chip shots, the type of spin control they have, what the distance is off the tee in addition to the spin rate on the ball. The dimple pattern of the best ball for your game may be very different compared to similar handicap players. This amateur golfer may want to spend a bit more for a tour brand.
What is the Best Golf Ball for Beginners?
We believe an amateur golfer and a beginner golfer are very different, and we actually did some testing on several golf balls in this category. This golfer is learning about hitting the ball and are likely playing several golf balls on the market, playing distance balls to improve their distance off the tee.
The beginner is going to be a high handicapper, with very little experience and will be a bit more concerned about getting a good ball for the money. If the price is right, the distance off the tee, spin control, spin rate, greenside control, and brand are all going to be secondary.
You can see our choice for the best golf balls for beginners on our previous review.
The Top Amateur Golfballs
What Golf Ball is Best for Slow Swing Speeds?
Taylormade Project (s) Golf Balls
Best Value for a Quality Ball
The all-new design of golf balls released in 2018, which is TaylorMade Soft Ball option comes in a 3-layered design with improved performance due to the all-new dimple and core pattern.
The new core, Dual Distance, features a softer and larger inner core, which allows for a reduction in spin with a great feel.
For maximum distance and velocity, maintained due to the new resilient outer core made from polymer.
Less spin, off your drivers, and longer irons giving your less spin on the greenside because of the ionomer cover, made even softer material.
The 342 dimpled ball reduces drag, and there is a major reduction in backspin, allowing more distance from your swing.
- The improvement of the feel and control because of the soft ionomer cover especially around the greens
- Improving your feel and a reduction in spin created by the new larger and softer inner newly designed Dual-Distance Core
- Improving the feel while maintaining velocity with the new more resilient and a softer polymer outer
- The rating of compression is 60 for the feel for the TaylorMade
- With a significant reduction in drag for extra distance as well as the reduction of backspin created by the all-new 342 dimple pattern
- 3 piece Construction
- A handicap target of 8-18
Callaway Golf Supersoft Magna Golf Balls
A step up from Super soft golf balls, the Supersoft Magna is an oversized ball that flies straight and is easy to hit. These feature an ultra-low compression core that allows for extra speed over longer distances with increased accuracy.
The HEX Aerodynamics design helps reduce the drag and keep it lifted to go the distance. The Soft Trigonometry cover is formulated for a good feel and a wedge spin to stop the shot and keep it where you need it.
Srixon Men’s Soft Feel Golf Ball
The Srixon are unique golf balls as they are used by an array and variety of players, no matter the handicap! (But is typically used by those with a slow swing.)
With a soft feel to the greens from the tee-off, the softcore uses all the stored energy released on your stroke to maximize the distance traveled.
The soft feel gets softer as you move towards the center as per the design of the resilient core.
This gives the player a high trajectory and greater lift with less effort sending your golf balls at greater distances.
KLS 3-Piece Urethane Cover Golf Ball
The new KLS 3-Piece Urethane Cover Golf Ball by Kirkland Signature Performance Plus was designed with both competitive and recreational play in mind.
The Kirkland Signature Performance Plus gives you a longer-lasting durable ball that has an amazing responsive feel when you putt as is made of a soft urethane cover casing.
It is constructed with a rubber core that is made highly elastic, with low compression material, and gives a softer feeling but with at higher speeds.
It provides a ball trajectory that can only be explained as penetrating because of the 338 dimpled pattern.
A three-piece construction to control not only the speed but spin as well with a huge boost in speed mantle but creates controlled spins with the longer irons and around the greens with your shorter irons it generates a higher spin.
This will become your favorite new balls quite quickly because of the playability. Because it holds the greens well, and this great feel it is an excellent value for the money.
For any ball at this price point, it not only flies off the tee faster but off the shelves too.
Bridgestone 2019 e6 Golf Balls
The new Bridgestone 2019 e6 Golf Balls come equipped with consistent engineering. They are aerodynamically designed to add that extra distance.
Bridgestone offers a soft feel that can only come from a heritage of constructing high-quality, low compression cores for golf balls. The e6 falls perfectly in line with that heritage.
For all those moderate swingers out there, this is the ideal ball for you. You will get huge distances and lift from this ball to compliment your type of swing.
Titleist Tour Soft Golf Balls
Designed to have the biggest Titleist core ever, golf balls from Tour Soft are known to have high ball speed and produce a responsive feel that translates to commanding distances.
New Cover Formula
These golf balls have a new 4CE grafted cover that is ultra-thin and is made with proprietary Titleist technology that produces advanced short-game control with a soft feel that is unmatched.
Titleists’ Biggest Core Ever
Designed with the biggest Titleist core ever, Tour Soft golf balls produce high ball speed and have a very responsive feel. The end result is an amazing distance that will give you a commanding lead.
The 342 spherically-tiled cuboctahedron dimple design produces penetrating trajectory and consistent flight.
After playing with the Srixon Soft Feel for several seasons, I have been happy with the experience as a 23 handicap golfer.
The new Titleist Tour Soft Golf Balls take the decent spin, good distance, soft feel, and other amazing qualities of Srixon balls, and takes it up a notch or two.
When golfing at our regular course, the ball usually ends up several yards further down the fairways and feels soft off the face. However, I enjoy the ball most around the greens as it feels and sounds great off my wedges, and holds really well for a ball at that price point.
Overall, if you are willing to spend $30-$35 for a dozen, these balls will be a wonderful addition to your ball collection. I am truly impressed.
That said, the Srixon Soft Feel is still my ball, and I plan to use it 75% of the time. Why? The price is great at just $18-$20 a dozen. Therefore, I won’t feel as bad losing a few balls while playing a tighter course.
Vice Pro Golf Balls
Most people cannot tell the difference between the Vice Pro and Pro V1 balls. After all, the spin around the green and putting are the same for the two types of balls. However, I usually get up to 10 yards off-the-tee when using the Vice Pro.
In many cases, I usually match or even go past my buddies when using the Vice Pro ball. As with other reviews, I got two rounds with the Vice Pro ball, and it was a little marked up. The performance of the ball was so close to the Pro V1 that there is no need for any control or distance adjustments regardless of the club being used. A great professional golfer friend of mine advised me to pick a ball and stick with it to maintain consistency, which is a great tip.
For over four decades, I have played Titleist, and I can say with great authority that the Vice Pro ball will probably be my ball for a long time because of two things; price and playability. Besides, I will not feel a lot of pain when the new ball goes into the water or desert.
The only noticeable difference between the Vice Pro Golf Balls and the Pro V1 is the exterior scuffs, which is a bit more. Therefore, you need to avoid the cart path.